Woo Mail from readers 2.10.2010
February 10, 2010 by samuelpwoo
Filed under Random Thoughts & Nonsenses, Woo Mail
SamPWoo.com – Here are the e-mails I have received:
Great article
You probably have never played hockey in your life. Carter won’t be suspended for finishing a check in front of his own goalie. Everyone knows if your going to go hard to the net, you better keep your head up. But I’m sure you knew that…
Your theory has no merit. You do a great job of stirring emotions to your readers, but as a journalist for hockey, you suck. Anyone can find vicious hits and list them for every team in the nhl. Its a vicious sport, but also the best sport in the world. I’m all for taking head shots away, but no one will able to take situations like that away from the game. It’s too high-speed, and with height differences like Carter-Salmela, it’s inevitable.
Maybe instead of writing about that unfortunate play, you could write about how lifeless and out of sync the Devils looked the second half of the game. Its been a scary trend recently, and an important point to bring up about your own team. Or you can whine about the Flyers…
carter hit
Sam Woo
You are a Homer!! The only people questioning that hit are Devils fans. That was a clean hit. No charging, he was gliding. It wasn’t a head shot it was shoulder to shoulder. Carter even lowered his shoulder to make the hit. Salmela ended up in a bad position on a clean hockey hit. Why don’t you spend your time writing about something important instead of being a flyers hater. This is hockey. Last time I checked it’s a contact sport.
No one in Devils land called out Scott Stevens when he layed out Kariya or Lindross or the many others.
Frickin homer=
Add Salmela to the latest Flyers’ list of victims…
Your article in regards to the Salmela hit is poorly written and off base. The day you can no longer hit with your shoulder and finish a check is the day I stop following the NHL. Salmela himself regards the hit as clean, and he was the one laid out on the ice. I agree the NHL has a major problem with headshots and injuries. I further agree that the flyers have had MORE than their fair share of such incidents. However, handing out suspensions and throwing you arms up in the air every time someone gets hurt is not going to fix the problem. Players get hurt on clean hits. Injury does not equal a dirty play. The league needs to call penalties and hand out suspensions based on the action, not the outcome. I think a constructive solution would be to make head shots illegal. Make it a double-minor penalty. It has worked with some success in college/pro football. Go blog about that instead of crying about a legit hit. I don’t recall anyone up in arms when Stevens laid people out with hits just like that. In fact he made a career out of it.
No Subject
Sam,
I think you have a short memory.
Stevens laid out Kozlov, ended Lindros’ career and almost killed Paul Kariya.
Aren’t you being a tad hypocritical about these hits?
I’m a Devils fan, that was a angled hit from behind last night but there is a reason Devils players did not attack Carter.
If there is a rebound and Salmela puts it in, it’s Carter’s fault for not hitting him.
Also Salmela is shorter than Carter and was ducking down while making his move.
last nights game
Sam:
wow that couldnt have been any more biased about last nights game.
avery did it 3 years ago to kovalchuk and last night it worked again…
don’t worry about last nights game the Devils are a better TEAM
Last night gaborik’s team won, and only for a difference of 3 minutes,
lundqvist was better than marty thats all.
Just worry about the devils power play
Game On
Devils Hockey Notes from past two games
Hey Sam Woo,
I read your articles and love what you say about the Devils. But I have to say that I am alittle dissapointed in all of the articles.. Not one article, whether it be in the newspapers or in your columns, mentions the poor play of Mike Mottau. I was at the past two games, the incredible comeback victory and the incredible disappointment in MSG. This team is lacking defensively, which is very uncharacteristic of a team that preaches “Defense First” for so many years. Mike Mottau is the main reason for all of our losses. Mike Mottau is just terrible! On Friday’s game, he had atleast two turnovers, sure he was +2 but that was only because goals scored on the PK doesn’t count against the +/-. His turnover on Saturday led to Callahan’s Goal. Everytime he is remotely pressured, he coughs up the puck. Don’t believe me?? Look at every single game this season. We Devils fans are tired of Mike Mottau and his pathetic play. I do not wish injury on any player, but if this guy tore his ACL, it would actually be a blessing in disguise. He is terrible and needs to go. Besides Mark Fraser, he is the only “Top 4″ defensemen to be at the optional skate this morning. Why?? Because he knows his poor play has costed the Devils numerous games this season. When Martin comes back, he surely needs to sit. Another poor player on Defense is White. He has meant alot to this organization, but his time has come and gone and is not worth 3 more seasons. Lamorillo needs to make a trade for a physical defensmen. Who you ask? Milan Jurcina from Columbus. Columbus is no way in playoff positioning and Jurcina is a UFA at the end of this season. And with what is going on in Columbus, he would be an absolute steal of a pick up. I would give up White, who brings experience to a young team, and Atlanta’s 2nd Round Pick this year to Columbus for the 26year old, 6-4; 233lbs Right Handed Defensmen. Also, why not critisize Neidermayer for his poor play as well. He has been getting alot of “stupid” penalties the past few games. When the team gets healthy, Neidermayer and Pando need to be moved to the 4th Line with Zarkhov. The top two lines remain the same, but you have to make MacAmmond, Rolston, and Clarkson as a No. 3 Line. These are just my 2 cents. Hopefully you can put some of this in your next article.
Thanks,




Comments
One Response to “Woo Mail from readers 2.10.2010”Trackbacks
Check out what others are saying about this post...[...] I’ve received a pretty large response to my latest blog, regarding Jeff Carter’s hit on Anssi Salmela in Monday’s game, so here’s my response to all of you who were gracious enough to write in. You can read the e-mails HERE: [...]